If you're looking for an opaque look, I would DEFIANTLY buy the normal version. As you can see from the swatches, the waterproof version looks streaky.
I found that, with the WTP version, I had to apply two or three coats to achieve the perfect cat eye look I was going for. The WTP version would be better for summer but would you REALLY want to spend 10 minutes putting on two or three coats of eyeliner? I know I wouldn't.
I also found that the WTP version doesn't last very long. I would put it on at the start of the day and within an hour, it had flaked off in chunks. I don't know if it's just my oily eyelids that don't hold the product very well or if it's like that with all skin types.
They both smudge a little but only if you apply A LOT of pressure and are very rough with it (which you shouldn't be around your delicate eye area). Overall, I think that the normal version's formula looks and feels the best on my eyes. I wouldn't repurchase the WTP version but I would repurchase the normal version (: || WTP: 5/10 Normal: 8/10
If you liked it, please give it a like and a share. Also, if you want to read more from me, I will be posting every Wednesday, Friday, and Saturday at 5pm GMT. Lastly, if you would like to go over to my personal blog, I post every Wednesday, Friday, and Saturday as well at the same time and you can find me here
Published by Aimee Louise Smith